TITLE: TESTIMONY
AUTHOR: ANITA SHREVE
Pages: 305
Date: 31/12/2008
Grade: 5
Details: Ryan Tubridy book club selection for January 2009
Library
In a private school in Vermont a sex scandal breaks when 3 boys are caught on tape with a 14 year old girl. During the time that follows, a lot of lives are changed for ever, while a few are utterly destroyed.
In this book, most of the people involved in the events leading up to that night, a well as those involved in the scandal itself, give their sides of the story.
This was an interesting book. For a while I wasn't sure if I'd end up liking it or not. What makes this book so different is that no verdict is given about the rights or wrongs of the actions taken by any of the characters. The narrator, in a way, is absent from the story, in so far that only the voices of those involved are heard. And while they may or may not say something about their own actions and motivations, or about their own responsibility or lack there off, it's left to the reader to make up their own mind about how to apportion guilt.
In another book, with another story this could be viewed as laziness or cowardice on the part of the author, but I don't think that's the case here. I'd be hard pressed to point the finger at any one person or action in this book and pronounce a guilty verdict. As in real life, the answer isn't that clear cut. And exactly that is what makes his book so good and thought provoking.
TITLE: CROSS COUNTRY
AUTHOR: JAMES PATTERSON
Pages: 406
Date: 28/12/2008
Grade: 3.5
Details: no. 12 Alex Cross Mystery
Library
Okay, so there's no denying that Patterson is a master storyteller. He knows how to grab your attention and hold it. He almost forces the reader to keep on turning the pages, thus racing through the book.
However, he appears to have been caught in a trap of his own making. Whereas this series of Alex Cross books started of as very good police thrillers, be it with horrific murders and inhumane perpetrators, he now seems to write from the believe that however gruesome the last book was, the next one needs to be even more extreme. And in doing so he has, for me at least, lost touch with anything resembling reality. The characters, both good and bad, don't read like they might even resemble somebody real anymore. And while I used to like the character of Alex Cross, with this book I lost a lot of my respect for him.
The story, in short, starts when an old friend of Alex' as well as her whole family is murdered. More murders of whole families follow and Cross and Co discover that the man in charge of the gang committing the murders is a Nigerian called "Tiger". When reports indicate that Tiger has returned to Africa, Cross follows him there, which brings him to a world filled with corruption and violence way beyond anything he could ever have imagined.
Like I said, the plot stretched my credibility too far. Would a man, who loves his family, leave them unprotected while a gang specializing in murdering families is on the loose?
Would that man travel to a part of the world he knows next to nothing about, to start a one man investigation (crusade might be a better word) without and clues, contacts or protection?
Would he survive everything that Cross goes through in the book? The answer for me is "no" to all those questions.
So, while I'll continue to read this series, I won't be buying the books anymore. I don't want to spend my money on cheap thrills and easy shockers when there are so many good books out there.
The mark for this book is based purely on its page turning power, not on the quality of the story.
TITLE: EAT, PRAY, LOVE
AUTHOR: ELIZABETH GILBERT
Pages: 346
Date: 26/12/2008
Grade: 5
Details: Non Fiction
Own
After a bitter divorce and a deeply felt but unsustainable relationship Liz Gilbert decides to take a year to reassess herself and her life.
She divides her year up into three parts and spends her first four months in Italy where she concentrates on learning Italian and eating good food. During this process she manages to retrieve some sense of fun and (mainly physical) strength.
The next trimester is spend in an Ashram in India, where meditation, hard work, healthy living and big struggles with her demons bring Liz insight into herself, her past, her motivations and insecurities. Thus enlightened she can at last leave the past behind her and start looking towards the future.
Which brings her to the final leg of her journey on Bali. Here, through a toothless medicine man and a female healer she is lead to love. The emotion that through its breakdown brought her on this journey in the first place.
This is a rather special book. The causes of the author's breakdown are recognizable, and her need to go out and find answers as well as herself is one I believe most people come across at some point in their lives.
Of course, not all of us are able to take a year out and travel in order to find our answers, but then, I don't believe that is necessary. I think answers may be found anywhere by those who truly look.
Gilbert's ideas about God and religion are close enough to mine to strike a cord. Having said that, I couldn't see myself doing what she did.
For me the message of this book is loud and clear; in order to be able to truly love another, you must first truly know and love yourself. And as hard as that may be to achieve, it does make perfect sense. If you're not happy in your own company, you will end up bringing that unhappiness into your relationships with others.
Elizabeth Gilbert has to be complimented on not turning this into a heavy, deep, moralizing and preaching book. She has managed to keep it light and at times fun, while sharing some important live lessons in an honest and accessible way.
In my paper reading journal I have several pages of quotes from this book. I'm not sharing these here, because what I take from this book is not necessarily what somebody else needs to read. And whereas this is a public reading journal, my paper one is still for me alone.
TITLE: SANTA CRUISE
AUTHOR: MARY & CAROL HIGGINS CLARK
Pages: 306
Date: 24/12/2008
Grade: 4
Details: A Holiday Mystery featuring Alvirah Meehan & Regan Reilly
Large Print
Library
Alivirah Meehan has won 6 tickets on the maiden voyage of the Royal Mermaid and invites Regan and Jack as well as Regan's parents to join her and her husband on the trip.
But, what should have been a few days of relaxing at sea soon turns into an interesting investigation. Starting innocently enough with two stolen Santa suits, things quickly turn more sinister with reported sightings of ghosts and an attempted murder.
These books are really just a bit of fluff and fun. There really isn't much of a mystery since most of the culprits are in clear view and identified almost from page one.
Still, this was an easy read, seasonal and fun, and I'll more than likely be reading another one next year.
TITLE: THE SUMMER HOUSE
AUTHOR: CHRISTOBEL KENT
Pages: 406
Date: 22/12/2008
Grade: 4-
Details: Large Print
Library
Rose Fell has left England for a tiny village in Italy after her divorce, but even after a year there she's still finding it hard to integrate.
Elvira Vitale, once a famous model and movie star spends her summers in the same village with her English husband who she's starting to distrust.
Ania is Romanian and works as Elvira's cleaner.
When a young girl is found murdered close to the village and Ania subsequently disappears the lives of the women are thrown together by a danger that for at least one of them is much closer than they could imagine.
This was a good mystery with some nice red herrings, but it wasn't a very satisfying read. The story moved too slowly for me with too much switching from one person to another. It wasn't exactly a struggle to finish this book, but the story wasn't calling me to finish it either.
TITLE: THE PAGAN STONE
AUTHOR: NORA ROBERTS
Pages: 305
Date: 18/12/2008
Grade: 5
Details: no. 3 The Sign of Seven Trilogy
Library
It was wonderful reading Nora Roberts as I like her best; writing a trilogy, and it was sad that this was the third book in this trilogy because now I have a wait in front of me before she (hopefully) comes with the next series of three.
In this third books things are about to come to a head. The Seventh of July is ever getting closer and with it the time of the final showdown. Either the six friends will destroy the demon once and for all, or it will win, destroying them and the world they know and love.
As Gage and Sybil grow ever closer despite both their independent streaks, it becomes clear that killing the demon will demand the ultimate sacrifice. But will love, only just discovered, really end so soon and so brutally?
I'm not sure why Robert's trilogies work so much better for me than her stand-alone books, but they do. And this one definitely didn't disappoint.
TITLE: A GATHERING LIGHT
AUTHOR: JENNIFER DONNELLY
Pages: 375
Date: 16/12/2008
Grade: 5
Details: Large Print
Library
Set in 1906 in the Adirondack Mountains (USA) the story in this book is part fiction and part (based on) fact.
Mattie Gokey (fictional) is the eldest daughter in a poor family and expected to take over when her mother dies. But Mattie has a talent for writing which she wants to take to college in New York. But with her father set against her ambitions and a local boy courting her, it seems that Mattie's dreams will remain just that.
During the summer, Mattie takes on a job in a local hotel. Grace Brown (fact), one of the guests there gives Mattie a bundle of letters and asks to have them burned. When Grace subsequently drowns under suspicious circumstances, Mattie ends up reading the letters rather then burning them, finding that even through the heartbreak of a stranger, her own future and decisions become clear.
This was a wonderful book. Mattie's fictional life, though hard and unforgiving is realistically described and quite inspirational.
Grace's (real) murder is heartbreaking. I would love to think that it served a purpose in real life, as it did in this novel.
